ok em, I tried that but it returned no search results.
I tried changing your line add_action('init','child_remove_searchloop');
to add_action('init','childtheme_search_loop');
which returns results without the previous repeated results problem, BUT they are outside of the content area again. I'm not sure why, my <p> tag is still in the edit. . . Tho I don't know php, so my edit may be calling the original thematic search results again, I’m not sure.
So this is my functions.php now:
// Search-loop edit
function child_remove_searchloop() {
remove_action('thematic_searchloop', 'thematic_search_loop');
}
add_action('init','childtheme_search_loop');
function childtheme_search_loop () {
while ( have_posts() ) : the_post();
thematic_abovepost(); ?>
<div id="post-<?php the_ID();
echo '" ';
if (!(THEMATIC_COMPATIBLE_POST_CLASS)) {
post_class();
echo '>';
} else {
echo 'class="';
thematic_post_class();
echo '">';
}
thematic_postheader(); ?>
<div class="entry-content"><p>
<?php thematic_content(); ?>
</p></div><!-- .entry-content -->
<?php thematic_postfooter(); ?>
</div><!-- #post -->
<?php
thematic_belowpost();
endwhile;
} // end search_loop